Evidence of time travel?

An Irish filmmaker thinks he has found evidence of time travel in a Charlie Chaplin movie.

George Clarke says a video from a bonus feature of the DVD to Chaplin's 1928 film "The Circus" shows a woman talking into something she's holding up to her ear.

It appears to be a mobile phone, although they weren't invented until the 1970s.

It's likely the actor is holding a hearing aid, but we won't be the judge.

Watch the video and judge for yourself!  Leave a comment below.  (All comments are subject to approval)

 

Comments

[Justin Seine]

If she is using a cell phone, who could she possibly be talking to and what is handling the signal???

[peter ivan kalaschenkow]

i think that there is a strong possibility that it is a mobile phone; the way the finger are formed around this object definetly make me think of how a mobile phone is held. and the lady was talking on this device. someone mentioned to me about this earlier today and he told me he thought it was a hearing device, but i really don't know if they even had hearing devices back then. but than again idk b/c well to use a cell phone you need a tower, and i don't think those were even around until the 1940s or 50s. even if this is evidence of a time traveler, does it even matter now? that was back in 1928 and now its about to be 2011. and that was almost 90s years ago so it's probably irrevelant. or maybe you have a copy of the movie that has been tapered with?

[JIM ARKINS]

EASIEST ANSWER IS A REMAKE OF THE ORIGNAL MOVIE SCENE ,MAKES A GOOD URBAN LEGEND. REMINDS ME OF THE BOY GHOST SCENE FROM THREE MEN AND A BABY.

[Siddharth Dubey]

Even if it is a mobile phone.... U need a signal... for that we need towers/satellites... i don't believe all that was there.... so I don't believe it was a mobile phone.... Mostly a Pocket radio which the above denies but....